Is the From Nightmares booster box worth it?
A lottery — value in a few cards
The booster box costs €113.67 today (Cardmarket trend). 18 cards are worth €5 or more — €846.55 together, 7.45× the box price. The top five cards make up 82% of the whole set’s value.
How cards are priced
Most cards in any set are commons worth cents. Whether a box pays off depends on hitting one of the few top cards.
Most valuable cards in the set
Full set →| # | Card | Set | Price today | 30 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Cloud 19-114 | From Nightmares | €610.00 | -36% |
| 2 |  Lightning 19-082 | From Nightmares | €60.00 | 0% |
| 3 |  Warrior of Light 19-128 | From Nightmares | €35.00 | -7% |
| 4 |  Prishe 19-111 | From Nightmares | €19.50 | 0% |
| 5 |  Rydia 19-068 | From Nightmares | €16.78 | -31% |
| 6 |  Cherukiki 19-109 | From Nightmares | €12.00 | 0% |
| 7 |  Unei 19-119 | From Nightmares | €11.64 | -1% |
| 8 |  Bahamut 19-130 | From Nightmares | €10.00 | +288% |
| 9 |  Sarah (MOBIUS) 19-024 | From Nightmares | €10.00 | 0% |
| 10 |  Sabin 19-010 | From Nightmares | €9.99 | -9% |
| 11 |  Hilda 19-117 | From Nightmares | €8.27 | -4% |
| 12 |  Edgar 19-003 | From Nightmares | €7.50 | +3% |
| 13 |  Larsa 19-100 | From Nightmares | €7.00 | 0% |
| 14 |  Y'shtola 19-124 | From Nightmares | €6.87 | -5% |
| 15 |  Golbez 19-077 | From Nightmares | €6.60 | -67% |
| 16 | Prishe 19-111 | From Nightmares | €5.40 | +42% |
| 17 |  Lightning 19-138 | From Nightmares | €5.00 | -33% |
| 18 |  Leon 19-017 | From Nightmares | €5.00 | -41% |
| 19 |  Behemoth 19-066 | From Nightmares | €4.58 | -52% |
| 20 |  Makki-Chebukki 19-049 | From Nightmares | €3.96 | -35% |
Prices: Cardmarket trend, updated daily — as of Oct 30, 2026.
How to read these numbers
The full-set value is what all cards would cost as singles. One box won’t complete the set and the rarest cards are rare, so we focus on cards from €5. If they are worth many times the box price, the set is rich in valuable cards; if value is concentrated in a few cards (high top-5 share), opening is a lottery.
If you want a specific card, buying it as a single is almost always cheaper. A box makes sense if you enjoy opening, play limited/draft or collect sealed product.